Agenda and minutes

Councillor Conduct Committee - Wednesday, 7th December, 2016 6.30 pm

Venue: Room 3, Civic Centre, Silver Street, Enfield, EN1 3XA. View directions

Contact: Penelope Williams 

No. Item


Welcome and Apologies


The Chair welcomed everyone to the meeting.  There were no apologies for absence. 



Any member who wishes to appoint a substitute for this meeting must notify the Monitoring Officer in writing, before the beginning of the meeting, of the intended substitution.


Any notifications received will be reported at the meeting.


There were no substitutions for this meeting. 


Declaration of Interests

Members are asked to declare any pecuniary, other pecuniary or non pecuniary interests relating to any items on the agenda. 


There were no declarations of interest. 


Independent Person - Extension of Term of Office pdf icon PDF 195 KB

To receive a report, from the Monitoring Officer, on options for extending the term of office of one of our Independent Persons. 


Sarah Jewell, Independent Person, left the meeting while this item was being discussed.


The Committee received a report from the Monitoring Officer on options for extending the term of office of one of the independent persons.  (Report No:  166)




1.               The Monitoring Officer’s recommendation that we should extend the appointment for a further two years to ensure consistency.  That she valued the input, guidance and support that she had received and felt that it would be a benefit to the Council to extend the appointment. 


2.               The committee had no objections. 


3.               Sarah Jewell had indicated her willingness to continue. 


AGREED to recommend that Council extend the term of appointment of Sarah Jewell (Independent Person) whose current term of office came to an end on 8 October 2016 by two years to 8 October 2018. 


Sarah Jewell returned to the meeting. 


Update on Complaints Received pdf icon PDF 132 KB

6.1           To receive a report from the Monitoring Officer concerning a complaint received against a councillor. 


6.2           To receive a verbal update from the Monitoring Officer on other complaints received. 

Additional documents:


The Committee received a report from the Monitoring Officer on a complaint that she had received from Councillor Neville about Councillor Erbil.  (Report No: 167)




1.               The part of the complaint concerning the first offence committed by Councillor Erbil, was set aside as it was felt that too much time had passed since the incident had occurred. 


2.               The rules of natural justice applied.


3.               Even though the matters had been dealt with by the Courts, it was felt that the Councillor Conduct Committee should have the opportunity to consider the complaint, hear the representations from both the complainer and the complained against, to decide whether the councillor had breached the Council’s Code of Conduct and whether any sanctions should be imposed. 


4.               The advice of Christine Chamberlain, Independent Person that the earlier matter should be set aside, but that the second matter of the two more recent offences and the misleading statement should be considered at a hearing of the committee.  


5.               The matter had previously been dealt with by the Labour Party’s own internal complaints procedure. 


6.               Following a discussion, and consideration of the eligibility criteria for complaints as set out in paragraph 3.2 of the Council’s procedure for handling complaints, the committee agreed that a hearing should be held. 


AGREED that a hearing should be arranged to consider the complaint.  A date would be found in the New Year. 


The Monitoring Officer reported on the other complaints under consideration. 


Complaint 1 – the Monitoring Officer had received a complaint, from 50 people against 38 members of the majority group, in regard to their behaviour at the Council meeting held on 21 September 2016. 


Two of the original 50 signatories to the complaint had subsequently contacted the Monitoring Officer independently to advise her that, although they had attended a meeting concerning the complaint, they had not signed the complaint letter.


The Monitoring Officer reported that she had considered the complaint with one of the Independent Persons, Sarah Jewell, and had decided that it did not meet the criteria for eligibility as set out in Paragraph 3.2 of the Procedure for Handling Complaints.  She had decided that as legal action was also under way, and it would be more appropriate for the complaints to be dealt with under another complaint procedure as they did not relate to members.  In this case there was no right of appeal against the Monitoring Officer decision. 


Complaint 2 – This complaint, received from a member of the public against Councillor Anderson, was subject to a live investigation and was being considered by external lawyers. 


Complaint 3 – This complaint, received from Councillor Neville regarding Councillor Chibbah, was still being considered by the Monitoring Officer. 


Complaint 4 – This complaint, from a member of the public against Councillor Erbil, was being considered in consultation with one of the Independent Persons. 


The Monitoring Officer thanked the independent persons for their outstanding help in assisting her in these matters.


A further update would be  ...  view the full minutes text for item 249.


Minutes of the Previous Meeting pdf icon PDF 97 KB

To receive and agree the minutes of the meeting held on 10 October 2016 as a correct record.


The minutes of the meeting held on 10 October 2016 were received and agreed as a correct record. 


Work Programme 2016/17 pdf icon PDF 129 KB

To note the work programme for 2016/17 and agree any changes. 


The Committee considered the work programme for 2016/17.




1.               That items on the review of the procedure for handling complaints and the review of members’ expenses would now be considered at the meeting to be held on 2 March 2016. 

2.               The update from the Independent Person training would be postponed to the first meeting of the new municipal year. 


AGREED to note the work programme for 2016/17 as amended. 


Dates of Future Meetings

To note the dates agreed for future meetings of the Committee: 


·       Thursday 2 March 2017


NOTED the dates agreed for future meetings of the Committee as follows:


·       Thursday 2 March 2017